Wednesday, April 01, 2020
As the story starts out, I was reminded of the "Heart of Gold" episode of Firefly because of its combination of Western and fantasy/sci-fi tropes. Aside from the fact that they both begin at a brothel, the stories aren't similar, but the feeling of this novel owes a debt to Joss Whedon -- not just Firefly but also a good dose of Buffy. Davis has woven a complex and immersive landscape for this book. The Wild West stuff mixed up with this crazy paranormal stuff could have been a colossal train wreck, but she's made it effortlessly fit together.
The plotting of this story is relentless. We never really get a break as we careen from one moment of peril to the next. That pace is hard to maintain and at some point it starts to feel contrived. Just how many near-death situations can these girls escape? The ending fizzles out as Davis can't one-up herself enough to create a true climax. All of which leads us to the other issue: character building. I'm not going to say that she didn't put a lot of effort into these characters, but they are fuzzy and amidst all of the action I sometimes had trouble keeping straight who was doing what. Five (six if you count the boy) characters are a lot to sort through and build up to be sufficiently distinct (I never did quite figure out Tansy and Mallow in particular). Major kudos for creativity and an excellent setting, high marks for a story I got fully engrossed in, but maybe do less and make more of it by building up those characters and throttling back on the mayhem?
Sunday, March 29, 2020
Then Leah meets Jaspar, a mysterious girl living in an abandoned house in the woods. Jaspar is fun and exciting, and most important of all Jaspar doesn't look at her with the pity that everyone else does. Through the friendship that develops between them, Leah finds the will to move beyond her grief and see with a clear eye how encumbered it has made her and her family. But Jaspar's situation is dire. Can Leah help her in return or are some problems simply too big to take care of?
A lot of loss and pain in this book but in the end a lot of hope as well. Snyder avoids easy solutions and no one person saves the others. Instead it becomes a team effort where adults and children come together and teach and learn from each other at the same time. The end result is a moving story about taking risks and committing to others in order to break through unhealthy coping mechanisms. While elements of the plot are tired and familiar, the strength of this novel comes in its affirming and inspirational message, well written and effectively delivered.
Saturday, March 28, 2020
Being a girl proves harder than she expected. There's the natural worries of passing, but Zen also find that being a girl involves tricky social skills with which she is not familiar. She knows that being a girl feels right, but doing it right does not always come to her. She doesn't know to be wary around queen bee Natalie. While prim Margaret seems like she would make a good buddy, her conservative religious family proves to be a no-go. For safety and comfort, Zen is drawn to a group of misfits, made up of racial and sexual minorities trying to fit in.
Zen is far more than a trans girl. She has major computer skills. When a hacker defaces the school's website with racist and transphobic graffiti, Zen leaps into action, helping the school track down the perpetrator. All along the way she worries about finding out that the person who did this is likely someone she knows, someone who may not even realize that they have attacked her.
A complicated collection of ideas that surprisingly works. The major plot line of Zen learning how to be a girl is handled quite well. Zen both addresses her frustrations with the boy parts of her (she's well aware that as she enters puberty that things will get harder) and with learning the skills to reinforce and validate her femininity. Related to this, there's a lovely series of interludes where various characters describe how Zen appears to them, with even the most reluctant observer agreeing that Zen is a girl. Subplots about tolerance of cultural pluralism (Muslims in one instance and homosexuals in the other) neatly intertwine. Zen's two aunts, their marriage, and the overall non-traditional family they form is another component.
I also appreciate the things that the story doesn't do. No traumatic outing scene. No widespread bullying at school (mean girl Natalie aside!). No family screaming match. No grand gestures or speeches. It all ends on a high note and, while little external has actually changed, we get the sense that Zen is just a bit closer to her happy place. That opens us to a sequel or just a nice slice of Zen's growth.
Sunday, March 22, 2020
Salva is a young South Sudanese boy who is forced to flee for his life when soldiers attack while he is at school. Separated from his family, he struggles to survive, crossing inhospitable terrain and ending up in a series of refugee camps and dreaming of a better life. Told in alternating voices, the stories of Nya and Salva eventually connect in a surprising and dramatically appealing way.
Almost certainly, this book is read more often for a classroom assignment than for leisure, but it is easy and quick to read. Largely based on the real-life experiences of Salva Dut, one of the "lost boys" of Sudan who were rescued from Kenyan refugee camps and resettled in the United States, the book is pretty intense reading. People get killed and die horrible deaths. While retold in an entertaining way, the mood is factual and it reads like non-fiction.
Ashish is a formidable basketball player. Popular and friendly, he has a way with girls. They love him and he has flitted from one relationship to another. When he is cruelly dumped by Celia, however, things are different. He really liked her and the rejection sends him into a funk. He simply can't get over her. With his charm failing him, he throws himself at his parents for help. They are convinced that they can find him the perfect girl and Ashish is just desperate enough to take them up on the offer. They find Sweetie.
Ashish and Sweetie actually have chemistry, but Sweetie's mother puts the kibosh on the whole idea. Afraid that her daughter will become the butt of jokes and be humiliated because no one as handsome as Ashish could possibly want her overweight daughter, she forbids them from being together. But they end up going behind her back. Ashish's parents, less than thrilled at the idea, force them to go on a series of unusual dates (the first of which is to the temple) that surprisingly solidify the respectful relationship that develops between Ashish and Sweetie.
The result is a sexy romance that strikes all the right notes: a couple of kids with a very mature perspective on what makes a relationship work; a healthy respect for tradition, family, and (gasp!) even religion; and a heartwarming story about people who truly don't let bodyshaming control their lives. As with When Dimple Met Rishi, Menon has created a joyful story filled with contemporary Desi characters that transcend stereotypes, while remaining true and respectful of those cultures. This is an all-round winner!
Friday, March 20, 2020
And for a child, the things that mattered most were often trivial. Ali's strongest memory of the day the bombs started to drop was of knocking his brother off the top score on their favorite video game. And while he would witness atrocities like summary executions, his mother's decision to burn his comic books when they ran out of fuel made a bigger impact at the time.
The book is more of a memoir than a children's story. Reading it, I tried to picture whether a modern child could even relate to this moment in history. It's too recent to be considered history and too long ago for even their parents to remember. Admittedly it's fascinating to read the first-hand account. I'm always interested in seeing how children process the horrors of war. Overall, though, the writing is stark and functional and there's not much of a story.
Tuesday, March 17, 2020
Silly princess fantasy stuff for fans of The Princess Diaries. We'll keep on hold the non-existence of the Scottish royal family or any of the far-too-easy way that Millie manages to become chummy with them. Instead, we'll just enjoy this funny rom-com about two pretty girls in the Highlands. The dialogue is smart, the story briskly paced, and Millie makes a perfect doe-in-the-headlights for this make believe fairy tale.
Saturday, March 14, 2020
Smith (better known as the voice of Lisa Simpson) dabbles here with a enjoyable but unremarkable middle grade book. Lorelei is a sympathetic companion and full of insights about her friends and family. The struggles she engages with will feel familiar and readers will instantly relate. Given the rather lengthy nature of the book (340 pages), it is frustrating that nothing really get resolved. Instead, we must settle for the satisfaction that Lorelei by the end is beginning to learn how to cope and accept responsibility for the things that are within her power to change.