Sunday, December 30, 2012
The True Confessions of Charlotte Doyle, by Avi
Charlotte Doyle is looking forward to her trip across the Atlantic aboard the Seahawk. But when the families with whom she is supposed to be traveling fail to appear, and members of the crew attempt to discourage her from showing up, she regrets the decision. But already out at sea, it is too late!
Between storms, stowaways, and seasickness, Charlotte has a lot with which to deal. However, it gets worse: the crew is mutinous and the captain is unhinged and cruel. Before long, young innocent Charlotte finds herself thrust into the middle of plots and counterplots, and ends up accused of murder!
It's a vivid and exciting adventure on the high seas and a modern classic tale that has won its fair share of accolades and prizes. It works, I think, because it is a good adventure with plenty of action, but features a girl, so draws in the girls as well as the boys. There's great technical detail, so fans of naval adventures have plenty to bite into. And it works on a human level as Charlotte has a heart and a strong moral core to make her an excellent heroine. It's not much of a book for a moral or lesson, but you don't read books like this to learn about human nature. Unfortunately, you do read books like this to be subjected to twenty course lesson plans in language arts classes (!), so if you are a grown up, enjoy the book as a free person!
Posted by Paul at 9:51 PM No comments:
Friday, December 28, 2012
Lucky for Good, by Susan Patron
At times, the unstructured format of the story makes it hard to follow and there is a frustrating way for seemingly important threads to become neglected, but the overall flavor is so unique and charming that it is easy to overlook the flaws. Even the folksy lifestyle of Hard Pan is applied lightly -- just enough to be enjoyable, providing us with a great collection of memorable characters, without becoming cloying or condescending.
Posted by Paul at 8:44 PM No comments:
Lyddie, by Katherine Paterson
Less outstanding for the writing than the extraordinary story it tells, Lyddie is a well-researched historical novel that will give you pause to reflect on how hard life can really be and how we rise to the challenges that we must face. Its lessons about perseverance have a timeless classic quality to them that often lands the book on summer reading lists. Lyddie's life is harsh, but she accepts it with a level of grace and determination that make her a very inspiring heroine.
Posted by Paul at 8:29 PM No comments:
Wednesday, December 19, 2012
Incarnate, by Jodi Meadows
But Ana is not convinced that she is as bad as Mom claims. And after eighteen years of abuse at her mother's hands, Ana is ready to strike out on her own. Ana's convinced that the answer lies in Heart, the capital city. There, she hopes to get some answers about her origins and find out why she is the only one who is not reincarnated from a previous life. On her way to Heart, she befriends a musician named Sam who becomes her guardian, mentor, and object of affection (although not quite her lover). Acid-spitting dragons, wraith-like beasts called "sylphs," and Ana's meddlesome and evil mother fight her along the way.
It's an interesting setting and premise, but the story itself is a bit too leaden with adolescent rebellion. Ana's evil sadistic mother is more fantasy than the dragons and the wraiths, and a bit too much attention is spent on her. I get the appeal to young readers, but the lengths to which Mom goes to get between Ana and Sam are ludicrous and some of the weakest parts of the story.
On a whole, the story starts off strong, but loses focus midway (about the time that Ana and Sam reach the city). At first, we have the interesting thread of how (after years of emotional abuse) Ana has trouble trusting Sam. But once the dragons show up, it starts getting weird, and the emotional growth is displaced by shooting and killing. With a multitude of loose ends, I became painfully aware by the end that there must be a sequel to come (sure enough, due out in January 2013!).
Posted by Paul at 9:05 PM No comments:
Friday, December 14, 2012
Second Chance Summer, by Morgan Matson
And so, Taylor has to return and face Lucy and Henry again. The return is difficult and her abandonment is not easily forgiven. She expected that, but what surprises her is how it rekindles old feelings and makes her reconsider not just the decisions of her past but how her fear continues to control her life. Her romantic feelings for Henry return and her longing to have Lucy back in her life points out the terrible costs of her tendency to run away. Eventual forgiveness shows that second chances are actually possible. The slow decline of her father, meanwhile, places some perspective on all this and how sometimes even a second chance is not enough.
Obviously, the ingredients here are guaranteed to be upsetting. Between the nostalgia, the longing for lost friendships, and a dying parent, there had better be a Kleenex box nearby when you read this book! And since I do like a book that makes me cry, I'm going to like this one. However, there are other things going for the book: Taylor's emotions (and her fears, in particular) are very honest and striking. The other characters have depth as well. In a lengthy novel like this, we really get an opportunity to get under the skin of them all and it is an enlightening journey. (The setting is beautiful, although I'm growing disturbed at the unusual socioeconomic status of the families depicted in these books! Where do middle class people who can't afford summer homes go to have an amazing summer of memories?).
Still, the storytelling has some rough spots. Matson has problems pacing the story, clustering events in spots and then having to skip past "a few weeks" or so until events get interesting. It's understandable, but one wonders if she couldn't have planned the story a bit better to have a less jumpy chronology. Also, dealing with lost romance and dying father may be too much for one novel. Surprisingly, it actually works, but for the first half of the book, I felt like there were really two different stories going on.
Posted by Paul at 4:12 PM No comments:
Friday, December 07, 2012
Breaking Beautiful, by Jennifer Shaw Wolf
As she tries to remember what happened and also tries to rebuild her life, she discovers that the people in her small town aren't exactly sure about her either. Gossip leads to accusations and Allie's troubled friend Blake becomes a suspect in a murder investigation. If only Allie could remember what really happened!
The story begins with a promising start, but it gets dragged out. Allie has a lot of trouble coming to terms with the abusive nature of her former relationship with Trip. Survivor's guilt and general denial seems realistic enough and some struggling from Allie adds to the drama of the story. But at some point, her refusal to seek help (or even tell the truth) becomes just plain annoying and implausible -- and more of an excuse to drag out the story than to explore the psychic damage of abuse or the recovery process from it. And the ending of the book itself is a mess as Wolf strives for maximum melodrama in resolving the story.
Posted by Paul at 3:02 PM No comments:
The Unwritten Rule, by Elizabeth Scott
On its face, the love triangle ought to be a pretty tired genre, but Scott livens up the story by introducing a mild sense of evil (in the form of Brianna). This is not done simply to make Sarah's betrayal of her BFF acceptable to the reader, but rather to add another dimension to it.
The story is also given legs by the way that Scott breathes real life into her characters. Sarah is often wiser and more articulate than her years, but this gives her a chance to send the reader on a guided tour of the dysfunctions of her peers and their parents (Brianna's mother is a particularly formidible character). So, while the action of the story doesn't surprise, the interactions of the characters do tread new ground -- particularly the complicated relationship between Sarah and Brianna.
Posted by Paul at 2:42 PM No comments:
The Diviners, by Libba Bray
However, New York is also full of strange and evil things. A murderer is loose in the city and engaged in a series of ritual murders. Evie's uncle, an expert on the occult, has been consulting for the police and very quickly Evie herself gets drawn into the investigation. Teamed up with a series of paranormally-enhanced and gin-addled friends, they are on the hunt. The question is whether they can stop the killer before he manages to end the world.
It's Libba Bray's typical collection of crazy and wild ideas, which combine supernatural thriller with pulp fiction detective novel. Bray has infused the story with a lot of detail, but there's no escaping the sheer corniness of the setting, which is part Ghostbusters and part Dick Tracy. Either way, this extremely long tome (578 pages, you chumps!) is more cinema than literature -- light and airy, and largely insubstantial. Obviously, since I read the whole thing, I can't have felt like it sucked, but it lacked the fun of Beauty Queens and ultimately seemed pretty silly. And the last forty pages of the book existed merely to pave the way for an unnecessary sequel, while avoiding any sort of closure.
Posted by Paul at 2:25 PM No comments:
Monday, December 03, 2012
What Can(t) Wait, by Ashley Hope Perez
It's a familiar story (Real Women Have Curves, anyone?), but a good one. And told in this unvarnished and authentic fashion (with enough R-rated material to get the book-banners salivating), the novel has a lot of appeal. It's gritty and sounds right (and not just because of the frequent use of Spanglish).
It's the character of Marisa herself that carries this story. If she had just been this virtuous hard-working young woman pursuing the American Dream, I would have gotten bored pretty quickly, but Perez gets extra points for allowing her to be flawed. You want her to succeed so very badly that when she screws up, it breaks your heart. But Perez doesn't milk it. For every mistake, Marisa dusts herself off and jumps right back into things. So, yes, she's tough, but she's got a lot of heart (and a thin skin on the things that matter to her) so she's also very endearing. I rooted for her from the start and stuck with her to the end -- and I think it paid off quite well.
Being a product of a nice anglo suburb, I don't tend to have much interest in urban culture (or stories placed in such settings), but a great heroine transcends their environment and anyone can enjoy this book. If urban latinas find something special to like in the book, so much the better, but white guys will like it too.
Posted by Paul at 4:41 PM No comments:
Subscribe to: Posts (Atom)