Friday, July 12, 2013
Beta, by Rachel Cohn
Clones are supposed to lack feelings and emotions, but Elysia finds that she has both. Clones are subservient and have no will of their own, but Elysia finds that she has that as well. That makes her a suspect -- a "Defect" -- and she must hide those feeling from her owners or risk being "expired."
Dystopias are far too trendy these days and it is inevitable that a decent "reality" writer like Cohn would give it a shot (anyone care to imagine what a Sarah Dessen dystopian novel would look like?). Surprisingly, it's a strong contribution to the genre. The story is fast-paced and generally consistent, avoiding too many annoying plot twists. The ethics and issues raised by the novel (ranging from struggling to meet adult expectations to drugs and peer pressure) will resonate with young readers. In sum, I enjoyed reading it.
My biggest complaint is with the ending that meanders a bit too much. Cohn both tries to tie up loose ends (often awkwardly) and simultaneously introduce a silly plot twist at the end that is designed solely for the creation of the need for the sequel, Emergent. Will someone explain to me why dystopian novels always have to come out as trilogies? Somehow Huxley and Orwell managed fine in fairly thin single volumes!