Sunday, October 18, 2015
Princess Academy: The Forgotten Sisters, by Shannon Hale
A wildly convulsive story that combines material from the first two books, while introducing new and interesting characters to the adventure. We move through life in the swamp to dealing with exploitative adults to invasion and war -- the pace is unrelenting! It also felt very rushed at the end and failed to gel as we are pushed into a series of crazy coincidences and convenient resolutions.
This last book in the series is notably more political than its predecessor (which is saying something!). The Disneyfication of the covers of the books in the series (now featuring wide-eyed princesses) seems symptomatic of a storyline which has become far too self-conscious in its message-making. If this is truly the last book in the series, then I will be happy that it wrapped before becoming too precious in its social commentary.
But let me wrap on a positive note. From the beginning, I've enjoyed the strength of the female characters. Even in the face of men with weapons and greater physical strength, the girls always manage to come up with plausible counter-strategies that rely on intelligence, cunning, and bravery (although admittedly more violence in this book than the predecessors). And even in a story that accepts that girls are subjected to training in poise and demeanor that boys are spared, Hale finds empowerment instead of shame in such feminine curricula. Yes, you can have your cake and eat it daintily too!
Subscribe to: Post Comments (Atom)
I did find this one the least plausible of the three stories. But I still like Miri, and I like the way the three sisters in this one developed their characters. The ending was cute! (Okay, not quite in keeping with the more serious political tone, but it felt like Hale was returning to what she wanted the books to be.)
Post a Comment