Saturday, August 17, 2019
I tend to like these bittersweet and nostalgic stories of friends growing apart. They are certainly common in books for middle grade readers. This one, though, is surprisingly cluttered. Full of subplots (including a strange abduction story that just is left dangling in the end), the story gets overwhelmed but everything else. There's bra shopping and the first periods as one would expect for a book targeted for girls in this age group, but even coming of age seems buried, despite its obvious relationship to Sara and Nadine's estrangement. Critics have lauded the book for its multicultural elements (both Sara and Nadine are bi-racial) but while a certain amount of attention is spent on Sara's Korean heritage, it's hardly an important element. The book is just noisy and distracting.
Friday, August 16, 2019
Elodee and her twin sister Naomi are turning twelve and drifting apart. The easy bond that they once had has frayed by a family trauma. So when Mom gets a job offer in Eventown, moving and starting a new life sounds like a great idea. And while Elodee has reservations about some of the strange things about their new home, she likes how nice everyone is and how easy the life is. But over time, Elodee's reservations grow stronger and she finds herself rebelling against the "even" way of life. This proves to have severe consequences for Elodee, her family, and the town as a whole.
A peculiar and fascinating tale that explores the costs and benefits of sacrificing risk and chance for the security of an unchanging world. While written for middle graders, the subject matter (which is ultimately about enduring tragic loss) seems a bit heavy for the target audience. The metaphor of the utopia also seems likely to be lost on them. Adults however will find that the book has a lot to say in the end about love, community, memory, and the value of embracing differences. It's a beautiful and haunting story.
Sunday, August 11, 2019
As with the first book, a small dose of fantasy (teleporting and fire-breathing chickens) aside, this is a story about a girl working hard to achieve her goals. Packed full of useful and interesting instructions about chicken care, this delightful story will entice readers to learn more about chickens. Gently delivered messages about tolerance and forgiveness add substance. Copious illustrations throughout provide the icing on the cake. Fun, educational, affirming, and pretty to flip through -- what more could you ask of a middle reader?
Friday, August 09, 2019
Gaia and her sisters are mermaids, living off the coast of Ireland. In their society, men are in charge and their duty is to be demure and subservient to men in general and the Sea King in particular. He in turn uses her daughters to reward his most loyal soldiers.
Gaia, who has just turned fifteen has been informed that she will be given away to the odious (and much older) Zale. The idea repulses her. Her mother, who might have stood up for her, is gone. She was lost many years ago when she went to the surface and was captured and tortured by the humans.
And much more was lost. It was Gaia's mother who had carefully crafted peace between the mer-people and the wraith-like Rusalki (the spirits of wronged women who skulk in the dark and attempt to lure sailors to their death). But since her death, the King, Zale, and the other mer-men have been plotting war.
For her birthday, Gaia has been granted the opportunity to go to the surface for the first time. Mindful of her mother's fate, she is cautious, but nonetheless she becomes enchanted by Oliver, a human boy. Aware that she has no chance with him in her fishy form, she makes a bargain with a sea witch: she will be granted human legs but only for a short period. In that period she has to get Oliver to love her. Otherwise, she will die.
A grisly and dark retelling of The Little Mermaid with a strong feminist twist that becomes especially pronounced in the ending. It works but I found the story depressing. The essential message seems to be: love is pain and suffering, while freedom from men is death. It’s well within the eco-feminist cannon (although perhaps a bit more Andrea Dworkin than Susan Griffin), but this isn't usual territory for YA. Curious and original, but it is hard to imagine this dark and unhappy story finding much of an audience.
[Disclosure: I received an ARC in return for an unbiased review.]
Willa has issues with things around her that feel wrong. A sensory processing disorder makes certain sights, sounds, smells, tastes, or feels for her entirely unbearable. Every day is a struggle but through routine she is able to manage her adverse reactions. But any change is a challenge. She definitely doesn't like changes!
So when her father announces that he’s dating again, Willa isn't happy. Worse, his girlfriend isn't some stranger, but rather the mother of Willa’s BFF Ruby. Willa is not OK with the idea of Dad having a girlfriend. As much as she loves Ruby, she doesn’t want Ruby to be her sister. But change is in the air and Willa has to learn to cope with it.
A short, but well-written middle reader about a condition that I don’t believe has been touched on before. Willa's hypersensitivity can make her seem difficult, but Mackler navigates that challenge well, showing how difficult these situations are for her. At the same time, everyone’s a bit too perfect for my tastes (Willa’s parents in particular deserve some major reward!), but it’s a kind story that really just is focused on Willa’s difficulties. That might be the bigger issue: while we get a good picture of Willa’s struggles, there’s not much growth here. So, the pattern is Willa finds out about a change and then gets upset and then eventually moves on. Repeat. That’s actually pretty dull over the expanse of an entire novel.
[Disclosure: I received an ARC from the publisher in return for an unbiased review]
Friday, August 02, 2019
Littlepoors Warner and his sister Prayer have dreams of making some mun mun of their own and maybe becoming middlepoor some day, but their plans run astray and Warner ends up in jail. But then a well-meaning family of middleriches rescues him, trying to prove that, with a little mun mun, anyone can pull themselves out of poverty and littleness. But as the author grindingly makes clear, mun mun by itself can't change the legacy of who you are and where you came from.
With a wit that owes much more to Jonathan Swift's satire than any modern day dystopian novel, Andrews says a lot about class, privilege, and the inherent flaw in so many well-intended attempts to "fix" these social evils. The result can be depressing at points, but just as Gulliver's Travels was able to say so much of contemporary relevance in its day through fantasy, Andrews knows that the message is so much clearer when you are not expecting it. It's unwillingness to embrace either Left or Right will probably upset some folks, but there's little to argue with here.
The ending grows a bit weird as Warner becomes unhinged from his suffering and his character transforms to a dark anti-hero with whom it becomes hard to identify and sympathize, but the originality and biting observations of this allegory make this novel a stand-out work. It's a largely neglected book that deserves a wider audience. Highly recommended.
Ellie is having the worst Monday ever. Her parents are fighting, she gets a ticket for running a red light on the way to school, and her hair is ruined in the rain and it’s school picture day. In rapid succession, she then flubs a quiz, botches her campaign speech for class vice president due to a food allergy, and fails her tryouts for varsity softball. To top it all off, at the end of the day her boyfriend dumps her. What she wouldn’t give for a do-over!
And then she gets the chance: her whole horrible Monday repeats all over again. With the advantage of foresight, some things she can fix but others are worse for the meddling. But our chances are far from over and the day repeats again. She gets to tinker with and tweak this fateful day, never quite fixing it, because she’s really missing the big picture.
This would be the second Groundhog Day rip-off I’ve read this summer (see Opposite of Always on July 6th for the other one). It’s a cute device, of course, and overflowing with comic potential. In this case, it also has a weightier moral about being oneself instead of trying to be perfect for others.
The book does have a decent heroine and a fun story going for it. The guys are largely throwaway but Ellie is sympathetic with the right mix of skills and mistakes to make her believable. It makes for pleasant reading even if not treading much new ground.